The Concept of Group Rights from Universalist-Particularist Perspective and Beyond

Maria Bakalova; Blaga Blagoeva

doi:10.37075/YB.2019.1.08

Authors

Assoc. Prof. Dr Maria Bakalova Department of International Relations, Faculty of International Economics and Politics, UNWE Author
Assoc. Prof. Dr Blaga Blagoeva Department of Political Economy, Faculty of General Economics, UNWE Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.37075/YB.2019.1.08

Keywords:

Human rights, Group/collective rights, Universalist and particularist perspectives, Individual and the group

K38

Abstract

The issue of group rights is not a new one for political thought and practice. In late 20th-early 21st century it has resurfaced in political-international discourses and practices and normative-theoretical debates. The concept of group rights is of interest because of the normative, evaluative, and descriptive role it plays both in theory and practice and it is its debatable nature that we are interested in. Our main argument is that the concept of group rights reveals significant shortcomings for as much it is justified, at the same time it appears to be unsustainable (theoretically and empirically) for a number of reasons. We begin with a discussion of the concept of group rights in the universalist-vs.-particularist perspective and go beyond it to introduce the “group rights” debates and critically discuss its inherent controversies. We use a history-of-ideas approach to introduce the origin and evolution of the more general concept of “rights” as the natural setting within which the concept of “group rights” is tackled. Then we apply methods of substantive conclusions and of normative and political analyses of concepts that are pertinent to both normative political theory and to political science. The study reveals that straightforward and clear-cut “black-and-white” claims are hard to sustain when it comes to the justification, necessity, implications or functional usefulness related to the concept of group rights.

References

Bakalova, M. (1999). The Issue of Minority Rights in the Light of New Challenges. Human Rights in the Context of Sustainable Development (Ed. Yankov, G. and Blagoeva, B. and Yotov, Y. et al.), pp. 185-193.

Bakalova, M. (2003). The Debate on Liberalism-Communitarianism in the Context of Post-Communist Transition. Liberal Thought and the Dilemmas of the 21st Century (Ed. Yosifov, A. and Marinov, M. and Serafimov, M. and et al.), pp. 68-78.

Blagoeva, Bl. (1999). Contemporary Political Philosophy of Human Rights (Political Values and Human Rights). Human Rights in the Context of Sustainable Development (Ed. Yankov, G. and Blagoeva, Bl. and Yotov, Y. and et al.), pp. 97-102.

Bulgarian Explanatory Dictionary. (1976). Sofia: Nauka i Izkustvo.

Danchov, Nikola Georgiev & Danchov, Ivan G. (1993). Bulgarian Encyclopedia. Sofia: Elpis.

Anaya, S. J. (1997). On Justifying Special Ethnic Group Rights: Comments on Pogge. Ethnicity and Group Rights (Ed. Kymlicka, Will and Shapiro, Ian), pp. 222-231.

Azarov, A. (2003). Vvedenija v teoriju prav cheloveka [Introduction to the theory of human rights]. Prava cheloveka. Mezhdunarodnie i rosiiskie mehanizmi zashtita [Human Rights. International and Russian Mechanisms of Protection] (Ed. Azarov, A. and Reuter, V. and Hüfner, K.), pp. 8-48.

M Bakalova (2012). Minority Rights: Political principles and Legal codification (development of European minority protection system in the 90s). KSI Transaction on Knowledge Society, pp. 13-20.

Group Rights. (1994). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203887035.ch25

Benhabib, S. (1996). 'Nous' et 'les Autres' The Politics of Complex Cultural Dialogue in a Global Civilization. Multicultural Questions, 44-62. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/019829610x.003.0003

Brubaker, R. & Cooper, F. (2000). "Beyond Identity". Theory and Society, 29(1), 1-47. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/a:1007068714468

Conrad, Hannah Keziah (2014). A Thorn in the Eye: Bosnian Mixed-Ethnicity Families in a Polarized Land. UCLA. URL: https://escholarship.org/ctent/qt21x926zb/qt21x926zb.pdf (accessed June, 2019)

Eichler, J. (2015). Individual Rights in Collective Contexts: The Challenge of Reconciling Individual Rights with Collective Claims in Indigenous Community Participation. Essex Human Rights Review, 10(1). URL: http://projects.essex.ac.uk/ehrr/v10n1/eichler-individualrights-in-collectivecontexts.pdf (accessed May, 2019)

Милър, Д., Колман, Дж., Конъли, У., & Райън, А. (1997). Blackwell Encyclopedia of Political Thought : Guide. Sofia: Center for the Study of Democracy. ISBN: 954-477-021-6

Hardin, R. (1995). One for All. The Logic of Group Conflict. Princeton University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/20047222

Hidasi, Judit (2016). At the Intersection of Identities. Acta Universitatis Sapientiae, Philologica, 2016(1), 127-137. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ausp-2016-0009

Hohfeld, W. N. (1923). Is there any natural rights?. Fundamental Legal Conceptions (Ed. Hohfeld, W. N.).

Jones, Peter (1999). Human Rights, Group Rights, and Peoples' Rights. Human Rights Quarterly, 21(1), 80-107. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.1999.0009

Jones, P. (2016). Group Rights. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2016 Edition) (Ed. Zalta, Edward N.). URL: https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2016/entries/rights-group/ (accessed Mar, 2019)

Jovanovic, M. (2012). Collective Rights. A Legal Theory. Cambridge University Press.

Ethnicity and Group Rights. Nomos XXXX Yearbook of the American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy. (2000). New York University Press.

Kymlicka, W. (1995). Liberalism and the Politicization of Ethnicity. Group Rights. Perspectives since 1900. Key Issues N 3 (Ed. Stapleton, J.), pp. 233-257.

List, Ch. & Valentini, L. (2016). The Methodology of Political Theory. The Oxford Handbook of Philosophical Methodology. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199668779.001.0001/oxfordhb-9780199668779-e-10

Musgrave, Thomas D (1997). Self-Determination and National Minorities. Oxford: Clarendon Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198260585.001.0001

A Phillips & A Rosas (1995). Universal minority rights. Turku Abo and London: Abo Academy University for Human Rights, Minority Rights Group (International).

Pogge, Th. (1997). Group Rights and Ethnicity. Ethnicity and Group Rights. Nomos XXXX Yearbook of the American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy (Ed. Kymlicka, Will and Shapiro, Ian), pp. 187-221.

Ramcharan, B.G. (1993). Individual, collective and group rights: History, theory, practice and contemporary evolution. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights, 1, 27-43. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/157181193x00095

Saldukaitytė, J. (2017). Identity in Contemporary Society. Filosofija. Sociologija, 3(3), 161-164. DOI: https://doi.org/10.6001/fil-soc.2017.28.3.1

Taylor, Ch. (1999). Conditions of an Unforced Consensus on Human Rights. East Asian Challenge for Human Rights (Ed. Bauer, J. and Bell, D.), pp. 124-144.

Trompenaars, Alfons & Hampden‐Turner, Charles (1998). Riding the waves of culture : understanding cultural diversity in global business. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Universal Declaration of Human Rights of the United Nations. URL: http://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/ (accessed September, 2017)

Van Dyke, V. (1995). Collective Entities and Moral Rights: Problems in Liberal Democratic Thought. Group Rights. Perspectives since 1900 (Ed. Stapleton, J.), pp. 180-200.

IM Young (1994). Polity and group difference: a critique of the ideal of universal citizenship. Theorizing Citizenship (Ed. Beiner, R.), pp. 175-207.